Between Bethel and Dan: Clinically-Informed Biblical Counseling’s Failed Attempt at Balance

by May 22, 2025

And he set one in Bethel, and one he put in Dan. Now this thing became a sin, for the people went to worship before the one as far as Dan. — First Kings 12:29-30

Biblical balance is not always found between two available options. First Kings 12:25-33 teaches this principle in an incredible way, providing insight for those seeking to discern what’s being said in the current sufficiency controversy.

Because of Solomon’s disobedience, God took ten tribes from his son, Rehoboam, and gave them to Solomon’s enemy, Jeroboam (I Kings 11:9-13, 26-40). Once Jeroboam became king of the northern tribes, he promptly forsook God and sinned in ways worse than King Solomon. The primary feature of King Jeroboam’s sin were two golden calves, idols to be worshiped as part of his newly constructed religion (I Kings 12:28, 31-32). To prevent the nation from returning to David’s descendants and worshiping at God’s temple in Jerusalem, Jeroboam placed one idol in Bethel, near the southern border of Israel’s territory, and the other idol in Dan, near the northern border. This way, every worshipper in Israel would be located between Bethel and Dan, and presumably would choose a place of worship closer than the temple in Jerusalem (I Kings 12:26-30).

OLD ERROR, NEW APPEAL

One baffling quality of Jeroboam’s folly is its familiarity with Israel’s first breach of God’s covenant. Jeroboam virtually quotes Aaron who crafted Israel’s first golden calf at Mount Sinai. Both these idolatrous leaders told the people that their calves were “your gods, O Israel, that brought you up from the land of Egypt” (Exodus 32:4; I Kings 12:28).

Jeroboam took an old error and made it newly appealing to his contemporaries.

Read the complete article here.

Latest Articles

2025 Reading Guide

“An ignorant population is a perilous and expensive burden to any nation.” What J. C. Ryle (1816-1900) said about nations is equally true of churches. An ignorant congregation is a perilous and expensive burden to the church because all that God demands of his people...

The Sufficiency Statement

Earlier this month, a group of leaders in the biblical counseling movement that included scholars, authors, practitioners, and pastors wrote and signed The Sufficiency Statement. I am, gratefully,  one of those original signatories. I have never signed a public...

Nineteen Proper Responses to God and His Word

In his musings on practical atheism, Stephen Charnock reminds his readers why they must prize and study the Scriptures: “When the revelation is despised, the revealer will be of little esteem.”* This captures the basic truth that esteeming the Scriptures is the means...

How Do I Know God’s Word is My Delight?

The writer of Psalm 119, at times, expresses his own personal delight in God’s word (v. 16, 35, 47, 70). At other times in this mammoth portion of Scripture, the psalmist asserts that God’s word is his delight (see v. 24, 77, 92, 143, 174). The former is a statement...

CANCELLED: 09/11/24 MIDWEEK BIBLE STUDY

Due to the expected landfall of Hurricane Francine tomorrow afternoon, our usual Midweek Bible Study has been cancelled. Lord willing, we will meet again on Wednesday, September 18th to continue our study on The Home. All the earlier messages in the current series can...

My Heart Behind the Reading Guide

One of my heroes from church history is Thomas Bilney. There is much to say about him (maybe another time), but one reason I love Bilney is because he is most well-known for the significant impact he had on others within his spheres of influence. Whether through bold...